Root Cause: This has been confirmed as a bug that the user inputted values are not used when the statement evaluates to true.
Update to a fix version listed below or a newer version if available.
Fix Status: In Progress
Automic Web Interface 12.1.0 - Available
Automic Web Interface 12.0.5 - Planned release date: 2018-05-07
View the task properties from the workflow rather than from the workflow monitor to see the user defined values.